Small Business Hiring Just Cooled — 45% of Owners Still Can't Find Qualified Applicants
Small business hiring slowed in September, but the people problem did not go away. The National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB) reports that 51% of owners hired or tried to hire last month, down 5 points, and 45% of those owners found few or no qualified applicants. If you are planning to add staff this fall, the numbers tell you what to expect and how to prepare.
The Headline Numbers
NFIB's September 2026 jobs report, based on its survey of small business owners, found:
- Seasonally adjusted unfilled job openings fell to 32%, down 3 points from August but still 8 points above the historical norm.
- 51% of owners reported hiring or trying to hire, down 5 points.
- 45% of those hiring reported few or no qualified applicants.
- A net 17% plan to add jobs over the next three months, unchanged from August.
- 27% have openings for skilled workers, and 16% for unskilled labor.
NFIB Chief Economist Bill Dunkelberg summarized the picture this way: "Overall employment conditions are softening, though the small business labor market is still tighter than normal."
Softer, But Still Tight
The word to hold onto is "still." Openings dropped, but they remain 8 points above historical norms. Nearly half of owners who tried to hire could not find qualified people. That means the market has cooled without turning into an employer's market. If your plan assumed that applicants would suddenly be easy to find, the data does not support it.
The Small Business Employment Index fell to 100.6, below the 2025 average of 101.2. That is a modest slip, not a collapse, and it fits the broader description of softening conditions.
Labor Quality Is the Bigger Worry Than Labor Cost
One of the more interesting findings is where owners say the pain is. In September, 26% of owners cited "labor quality or availability" as their top operating problem. That was up 3 points and 14 points above the historical average. By contrast, labor costs as a top problem fell to 6%, the lowest since December 2020.
In other words, owners are less worried about what workers cost than about finding workers who can do the job. This matters for how you spend money. A higher wage may not solve a shortage of skills, but training, flexible scheduling, and a faster hiring process might.
Pay Is Still Rising, But More Slowly
On compensation, a net 28% of owners raised pay in September, down 3 points from the prior month. A net 20% plan future raises, up 2 points. So raises are still the norm, and more owners plan to give them, even though fewer gave them last month.
If you are setting pay for a new role, those figures suggest that competitors are still adjusting upward. Offering a rate that matched the market a year ago may now sit below it.
What This Means for Your Next Hire
Decide whether you are hiring for skill or for potential
With 27% of owners looking for skilled workers versus 16% for unskilled labor, skilled candidates are in higher demand among small firms. If you cannot find someone who meets every requirement, consider hiring for attitude and reliability and budgeting for training. Write down what a new hire must do on day one versus what can be taught in ninety days.
Move faster than you think you need to
When nearly half of hiring owners see few or no qualified applicants, the qualified ones who do apply are likely to receive other offers. A hiring process that takes three weeks may lose candidates to one that takes five days.
Check your classification before you hire
Some owners respond to hiring difficulty by engaging freelancers. That can work, but classification matters. Review the rules in our guide to independent contractors vs. employees before you commit, because misclassifying a worker can create tax and wage liability.
Build the true cost of the role
Wages are only one part of the cost of a hire. Payroll taxes, insurance, equipment and training all add up. Model the role in your profit and loss statement so that you know how much additional revenue the position must support. If you add employees, also confirm that your business insurance covers them, including workers' compensation where your state requires it.
If You Are Not Hiring Right Now
Falling openings do not mean you should ignore staffing. The net 17% of owners planning to add jobs over the next three months will compete for the same candidates you may want next quarter. Retaining the people you have is the cheapest way to avoid a hiring problem. Since a net 20% of owners plan future raises, check whether your current pay still sits near the market. A modest adjustment now may cost far less than a replacement hire later.
A Few Cautions About the Data
These figures come from a survey of NFIB members and reflect the opinions and experiences of those owners. They describe a national picture, and your local market may look quite different. A town with one big employer, a seasonal tourist economy, or a tight housing market can behave very differently from the national average. Use the survey as a guide to direction, not as a forecast for your own street.
It is also worth remembering that "net" figures such as the 28% who raised compensation reflect the share raising pay minus the share cutting it. They are not a simple count of owners who gave raises.
Bottom Line
September's report shows a labor market that is cooling but not cold. Fewer owners are hiring, openings are down, and labor cost is less of a top concern than it has been in years. Yet 45% of those who hire still cannot find qualified applicants, and 26% call labor quality or availability their biggest operating problem. The practical advice is to hire deliberately, move quickly on good candidates, invest in training, and keep a close eye on your payroll economics.
Source: NFIB, "NFIB Jobs Report: Small Business Hiring Slows in September," 2026.
Photo by Eric Prouzet on Unsplash
Looking for Business Funding?
Compare top business loan options tailored to your specific needs
The Small Business Marketing Playbook 2026
10-page no-fluff guide covering Google, SEO, reviews, Meta ads, and social media.
$29
FREE