Holiday Retail Hiring Is Set to Shrink Again — What It Means for Small Shops This Season
Big retailers are hiring fewer holiday workers than they used to, and that quiet shift could change how you staff your own shop this season. Challenger, Gray & Christmas projects about 450,000 seasonal retail jobs in the fourth quarter of 2026, down roughly 2.5% from the 461,500 added in Q4 2025. That earlier figure was already the lowest since 2008 and 15% below 2024.
For a small retailer, fewer big-box hires does not automatically mean an easier labor market. It means the competition for seasonal help is changing shape. Here is what the numbers say and how to plan around them.
The Numbers Behind the Slowdown
According to Challenger's holiday hiring outlook, retailers added 543,100 jobs in Q4 2024 and 461,500 in Q4 2025. During the peak seasons of 2019 through 2021, seasonal hiring exceeded 900,000. Transportation and warehousing followed the same path: 266,500 seasonal positions in Q4 2025, down 12% from 2024.
Andy Challenger, the firm's chief revenue officer, put the trend this way: "Retailers are leaning on automation, existing associates, and on-demand pools before hiring net-new seasonal workers." Retail Dive reported him describing nearly every hiring announcement this year as "smaller and more surgical than the pre-pandemic playbook."
Who Has Announced Hiring So Far
Only a few large employers have published their plans as of early October:
- Spirit Halloween: more than 52,000 seasonal associates across more than 1,500 stores in the U.S. and Canada, which the company calls its largest hiring event ever.
- Michaels: more than 10,000 seasonal team members. Nearly half of last year's seasonal positions converted to permanent roles.
- Bass Pro Shops and Cabela's: a nationwide hiring event in October, with about 4,000 positions according to Challenger.
Several major names had not disclosed 2026 targets. Amazon typically announces by mid-October and has hired 250,000 seasonal workers in each of the past three years. Bath & Body Works usually announces in early September and has added about 30,000 roles annually. Target historically hires about 100,000 and Kohl's about 90,000. Both are currently hiring without stated targets.
The silence matters. When the largest employers announce late or low, the effects on local labor pools tend to arrive later than the headlines.
What This Means for a Small Retailer
The Challenger analysis suggests smaller retailers may face intensified competition for seasonal workers, even as larger companies lean on technology and flexible staffing. There are two ways to read that.
The optimistic read: If big chains hire fewer people, more applicants could be looking for flexible work, which might make it easier to fill a few shifts.
The cautious read: The big chains are moving toward on-demand pools and converting existing staff to extra hours. That reduces the number of net-new seasonal jobs, but it also means experienced holiday workers have more places to pick up shifts. And NFIB's August survey found that 82% of owners who were hiring reported few or no qualified applicants, so quality is still a real problem.
The practical conclusion is not to wait and see. If the large players are being "surgical," you should be too.
Five Smart Staffing Moves for the Next Four Weeks
1. Start with the people you already have
Retailers across the industry are leaning on existing associates before hiring new ones. Ask your current team who wants extra hours between Thanksgiving and New Year's. Offering first pick of holiday shifts costs you nothing in recruiting and training.
2. Hire for the peak, not the whole season
Map your busiest days from last year's sales. If most of your volume lands on a handful of weekends, build a short-term roster around them rather than carrying extra payroll through slow weeks.
3. Make a conversion offer
Michaels' experience, with nearly half of last year's seasonal workers converting to permanent roles, shows how seasonal hiring doubles as a recruiting pipeline. If you expect to need help in January, tell strong seasonal hires up front that a permanent role is possible.
4. Post early and be specific
Spell out the shift dates, hourly pay, and expectations in your listing. Check your state and local rules on posting wages before you publish, since several jurisdictions now require pay details. Clear listings tend to draw more serious applicants.
5. Use on-demand help for spikes
If a staffing app or a local temp agency can cover a single weekend, that may cost less than a new hire you will have to onboard and train. Compare the full cost, including fees, before committing.
Do the Math Before You Hire
Seasonal payroll can quietly eat a good holiday. Before you add anyone, estimate the extra sales you expect from the additional shifts and compare them with wages, payroll taxes, and training time. A simple profit and loss statement from last season will show you which months actually carried your margin. If an added shift does not pay for itself, reduce hours instead of adding bodies.
Also confirm that your coverage is in order. More staff means more exposure, so review your business insurance policy for workers' compensation and liability coverage before new people start. And if you are tempted to bring in help as independent contractors to avoid payroll costs, read our explainer on independent contractor vs. employee first, because misclassifying seasonal workers can be expensive.
Keep an Eye on October Announcements
The next few weeks will tell you a lot. If Amazon, Target, and Kohl's announce numbers well below last year's, local labor markets may loosen. If they hold steady or recruit aggressively near you, expect higher wage expectations and faster-moving applicants. Either way, being ready early beats scrambling in mid-November.
The Bottom Line
Seasonal hiring at big retailers is trending down for the third straight year, and the companies doing the hiring are doing it in smaller, more targeted waves. For a small shop, the playbook is the same: lean on your own team first, hire only for proven peak days, offer a path to permanent work for your best seasonal hires, and run the numbers before adding a single shift.
Forecasts can change as retailers make further announcements, so check Challenger and your local labor market again before finalizing your holiday schedule. This article is general information, not legal or financial advice.
Looking for Business Funding?
Compare top business loan options tailored to your specific needs
The Small Business Marketing Playbook 2026
10-page no-fluff guide covering Google, SEO, reviews, Meta ads, and social media.
$29
FREE