Small Business Health Premiums Are Up 31% Since 2022 — And Most Owners Are Paying It Anyway
The median small business now pays $8,743 per employee for health insurance, according to a new analysis from Gusto. That is 31% more than in 2022. And despite the squeeze, most owners are choosing to eat the increase rather than cut the benefit.
The findings, reported September 28, 2026, draw on anonymized payroll and benefits data from more than 500,000 businesses with 2 to 49 employees, reweighted to reflect the broader U.S. small business population. Here is what the numbers show and what you can do about your own renewal.
The numbers behind the squeeze
- $8,743: median annual premium per employee in 2026.
- 31%: growth in that premium since 2022.
- $9,170: what businesses with 2 to 5 employees paid per employee.
- 35%+: premium growth for the smallest firms since 2022.
- About 17%: the increase after adjusting for inflation, the real rise in healthcare costs since 2022.
The smallest employers are getting hit hardest. With fewer people to spread risk across, a small group has less bargaining power, and one expensive claim can ripple through the next renewal.
Why premiums keep climbing
The analysis points to hospital, physician, and prescription drug cost inflation as the primary drivers. Those are costs an individual employer cannot negotiate away. The median projected premium increase for 2026 was 11%, so this year's bill was another step up on a steady climb.
Most owners are absorbing the hike
Here is the part that surprised us. Only 21% of small businesses offer health insurance, and that share has been stable. Among those that do, 52.7% of owners are absorbing the increase rather than shifting it to employees or dropping the benefit. Just 2.1% plan to drop coverage.
In other words, owners who offer insurance see it as a core part of keeping staff, and they are protecting it even as margins tighten.
The quiet shift to high-deductible plans
When owners do try to hold costs down, the main strategy is moving to high-deductible health plans paired with health savings accounts. HSA-eligible plan adoption rose from 9.6% in 2019 to 12.7% in 2026.
The tradeoff matters. A high-deductible plan can lower the premium, but it passes more out-of-pocket risk to employees. If you go this route, many owners help offset the exposure by contributing to employees' HSAs. Talk to your broker or benefits adviser about how contributions are treated for tax purposes before you commit.
What to do before your next renewal
Start early
Ask your broker for renewal quotes well before your current plan expires, so you have time to compare rather than accept the first number.
Compare plan designs, not just prices
Ask for side-by-side comparisons of at least one lower-premium option, including deductibles, out-of-pocket maximums, and network breadth. A cheaper premium can cost more if your team ends up outside the network.
Model the full cost
At $8,743 per employee, a team of ten is a six-figure line item once you count the employer share. Build it into your profit and loss statement as its own line so you can see how it affects margin as you hire or raise prices.
Survey your employees
Ask which features they actually value. Some teams prefer a richer plan; others would trade a lower premium for an HSA contribution.
Review your overall coverage
Health benefits are one piece of your risk picture. Our business insurance guide covers the other policies worth reviewing at the same time.
If you employ contractors
Some owners try to control benefit costs by using contractors instead of employees. Be careful: misclassifying workers can create bigger costs than the premiums you were trying to avoid. Review the independent contractor vs. employee rules before you change how you staff.
The bottom line
Premiums have climbed 31% in four years, and the smallest firms have seen even steeper increases. Most owners are absorbing the cost, but absorbing is not a strategy. Getting quotes early, comparing plan designs, and building the real cost into your financials will help you decide what you can sustain.
This article is for general information and is not insurance, tax, or legal advice. Consult a licensed broker or advisor for your situation.
Looking for Business Funding?
Compare top business loan options tailored to your specific needs
The Small Business Marketing Playbook 2026
10-page no-fluff guide covering Google, SEO, reviews, Meta ads, and social media.
$29
FREE